Canned beans, pasta sauces, various spices—we all have our must-haves for the pantry. Since new products are always lining up on grocery shelves, our editors cooked and tested our way through more than 200 products. It was a delicious task, and we determined what deserves a spot in the pantry.
We gathered our food editors and Test Kitchen experts to try out pasta sauces, spices, and meal starters in the BHG testing kitchens. From there, we took products home to see how much we liked them and whether they were worthy of the cost and shelf space. So if you're looking to liven up that vinaigrette for lunch salads or change up weeknight chicken dinners, we've got the best products to give your pantry a modern upgrade.
These are the 2024 BHG Food Awards product categories:
- Flavor Boosters
- New Basics
- Shortcuts
- Treat Yourself
RACHEL MAREK
Flavor Boosters
A spoonful, a drizzle, a sprinkle. It won’t take much of these seasonings and sauces to make everyone at the table say “Yum.”
RACHEL MAREK
Best Spiced Ghee: Paro Tarka Spicy Ghee Chili Crisp
Tarka, the practice of frying spices in oil—and clarified butter in this case—intensifies flavors. Warm slightly to wake up the cumin, chili flakes, and curry notes.
RACHEL MAREK
Best Chimichurri in a Hurry: The Spice House Green Chimichurri Mix
When fresh herbs aren’t handy, this dried herb mix is the next best thing.
RACHEL MAREK
Best Spicy Umami: Yondu Hot and Spicy Umami
A little of this fiery concentrate goes a long way in boosting savory flavor. Add a dash to stir-fry or soup for heat with depth.
RACHEL MAREK
Best Soy Sauce Alternative: Kikkoman Umami Joy Sauce
It’s gluten-free and soy-free, and you’ll never guess it’s made from a tomato base. The product is starting to roll out on shelves nationwide, so check the Kikkoman site to see if it's available in your area yet.
RACHEL MAREK
Best Salsa Macha: Somos Mexican Chili Crisp
The chunky chili oil with sesame and pepita seeds, garlic, nuts, and dried chile is an excellent topper for meats and veggies, but you’ll be tempted to eat it straight from the jar.
The Next Chili Crisp: Want to know what the next “it” condiment will be? Tarka? Salsa macha? Zhug? We predict you’ll be serving one or more of these spicy, herby sauces with just about everything.
RACHEL MAREK
Best Herb-Based Hot Sauce: Blank Slate Kitchen Zhug
This bright, herby hot sauce comes from Yemen and is popular around the Middle East. It's chimichurri meets salsa verde with an intensely spicy kick.
RACHEL MAREK
Most Innovative Spice Blends: Spiceology Rub Set 6-Pack
Any of these rubs will elevate weeknight chicken; also try the Black and Bleu on popcorn or the Chile Margarita around a cocktail rim.
Saucy Finds: Bottled sauces are a brilliant way to bring restaurant favorites home without buying a cart of ingredients.
RACHEL MAREK
Best Huli Huli Sauce: Poi Dog Huli Huli
It's a traditional Hawaiian sauce with sweet, teriyaki, and five-spice notes. Authentic huli huli chicken is basted with the namesake sauce and turned (or “hulied” in Hawaiian) over a hot fire. So light the grill and start slathering.
RACHEL MAREK
Best Vinegar-Based Barbecue Sauce: Duke’s Southern Sauces - Carolina Vinegar BBQ
The sauce made popular by North Carolina boasts a tangy, vinegary base with a hint of tomato for sweetness. Your pulled pork sandwich has a new best friend.
RACHEL MAREK
Best Dipping Sauce: Lillie's Q BBQ Aioli
Our new go-to dip for chicken tenders, the creamy garlic-mayo and smoky BBQ fusion is also transcendent on fries.
RACHEL MAREK
Best Sweet and Spicy Mexican Condiment: Siete Chamoy Botana Sauce
Chamoy is a tangy preserved fruit sauce made from mangoes, plums, or apricots; chiles; salt; and lime. Drizzle on tacos or fresh fruit or dip your margarita glass to rim with Tajín.
RACHEL MAREK
Best Miso Barbecue Sauce: Bachan's Miso Japanese Barbecue Sauce
Test Kitchen culinary specialist Emily Nienhaus describes this sauce as “a little like soy, fish sauce, and hoisin all in one.”
RACHEL MAREK
Best Fruit Salsa: Lola's Cherry Jalapeño Salsa
Fresh cherry balances the slight heat of jalapeños. Marinate a pork tenderloin or pour it over cream cheese and scoop it up with chips.
RACHEL MAREK
Best Flavor Base: Better Than Bouillon Sofrito Base from the Culinary Collection
A blend of veggies, herbs, and spices commonly cooked down to flavor Latin American dishes. Drop a teaspoon of sofrito concentrate into soups, salsas, or beans for instant flavor without chopping.
RACHEL MAREK
New Basics
Updated flavor or nutrient profiles plus convenient packaging reimagine and refresh classic pantry staples.
RACHEL MAREK
Ready-to-Go Squeeze Tahini: Seed + Mill Organic Tahini
If you’ve ever made a mess spooning tahini from a jar, you’ll love the slick squeeze bottle. Use it to make a quick dressing or drizzle over homemade falafel.
RACHEL MAREK
Best Canned Tuna: Tonnino Yellowfin Tuna with Jalapeño in Smoked Olive Oil
Our testers voted this tuna the best for eating right out of the can.
RACHEL MAREK
Best Savory Sprinkle: Just Spices Avocado Topping
Black sesame seed, flaky salt, and dried tomato—the pleasant surprise we didn’t know avo toast needed. Also excellent on eggs or roasted veggies.
RACHEL MAREK
Best Tuna Pouch: Chicken of the Sea Lemon-Garlic Tuna
No sad desk lunches here. Pack a pouch of this lemon-garlic tuna for a bright flavor boost.
COURTESY OF AMERICAN VINEGAR WORKS
Best White Wine Vinegar: American Vinegar Works Better Than Champagne Chardonnay Wine Vinegar
We’re toasting this vinegar made in small, barrel-aged batches and its incredibly distinct wine flavor. Save it for homemade vinaigrette.
RACHEL MAREK
Best Naturally-Sweetened Ketchup: Primal Kitchen A Tad Sweet Ketchup
Honey-sweetened with half the sugar of regular ketchup. (Trust us—you won’t miss the other half.)
RACHEL MAREK
Tastes-Just-Like-Homemade Relish: Bubbies Sweet Pickle Relish
Chunky pickles provide serious crunch in chicken or tuna salad and some heft to a Chicago-style hot dog.
RACHEL MAREK
Best Artisan Ketchup: Brownwood Farms Dill Pickle Ketchup with Bourbon
Pickle flavor is everywhere, and this fancy ketchup may be our favorite iteration of the trend yet. Gourmet burgers, anyone?
RACHEL MAREK
Best Everything Bagel Seasoning: Lil Bucks Everything Bucks SZNing
Upgraded with sprouted buckwheat, it’s the classic blend but with much more crunch and a nutty flavor hit.
RACHEL MAREK
The Best Dressed Balsamic
Fresh figs are a genius natural sweetener in this updated balsamic dressing.
RACHEL MAREK
Best Compound Butter: Kerrygold Sundried Tomato and Basil Butter Blend
Rich, flavorful, ready-to-spread Irish butter in a tub. Top your grilled steak and vegetables.
RACHEL MAREK
Most Versatile Cheese: Boursin Bites Garlic and Fine Herbs
Pop a few pearls into hot pasta to make an effortless creamy sauce or skewer them for on-demand apps.
RACHEL MAREK
Best High-Protein Oats: Bob's Red Mill Organic Protein Oats
Hey, all you non egg-eaters! These protein-boosted oats crafted from a special oat variety provide 50% more protein than regular oats (9 g per ⅓ cup dry oats).
RACHEL MAREK
Most Convenient Ghee: 4th and Heart Ghee Butter Sticks
Rather than scooping ghee out of a tub, measure it as smoothly as, well, butter with these sticks. Available in salted and unsalted varieties to meet all your cooking needs.
COURTESY OF GOODWHEAT
Best Stealthy Healthy Pasta: GoodWheat Pasta
Get the same flavor and texture of regular pasta but four times the fiber, thanks to a newly cultivated non-GMO wheat grain.
RACHEL MAREK
Shortcuts
If you're tired of old reliable time-savers, give this bunch a spin on evenings when schedules are tight.
RACHEL MAREK
Best Gourmet Pasta Sauce: Rao's Homemade Vodka Arrabbiata Sauce
A pleasing balance of two classics. Arrabbiata delivers the spice, and vodka makes the sauce cool and creamy.
RACHEL MAREK
Best Stir-Fry Base: McCormick Salt Free Sauté Business by Tabitha Brown Seasoning Mix
Big flavor from a versatile salt-free seasoning mix—add tofu or your favorite protein. These seasoning blends are just one of the many creative pursuits our March issue cover star, Tabitha Brown, has cooking on the front burner these days.
RACHEL MAREK
Best Shortcut Chili: Muir Glen Organic Chili Starter, Seasoned Fire Roasted Diced Tomatoes with Bell Peppers (Mild or Medium)
"I can’t believe chili this good comes from a can,” says food editor Jan Miller. Just add meat, beans, and heat. Prepare to be amazed. We were.
RACHEL MAREK
Best Refrigerated Dough: Pillsbury Corndog Wraps
Bring this iconic fair food home and skip the mess of deep-frying. Stick optional. For an easy app, try wrapping up wedges of Brie and jam.
RACHEL MAREK
Excellent Instant Side: Ben’s Original 10 Medley
Kick-start your grain bowl with a creative blend of 10 grains, legumes, and vegetables.
RACHEL MAREK
Best Rice Blend: Minute Jasmine Rice and Red Quinoa Cups
Say goodbye to a boring bed of rice. Fragrant jasmine rice brings flavor; quinoa boosts nutrition.
RACHEL MAREK
Best Frozen Vegetable Mix: Green Giant Restaurant Style Asparagus, Roasted Red Potatoes and Onions
Perhaps the only way these veggies finish cooking at the same time—roasty, caramelized flavor from stove top to table in 10 minutes.
RACHEL MAREK
Best Takeout-Style Noodles: Omsom Coconut Lemongrass Curry Saucy Noodles
Branch out from your typical ramen packet and try a trendy new spin on instant noodles. You're going to want to buy a pack to keep on hand when noodle cravings strike.
RACHEL MAREK
Quickest Pizza Topper: Volpi Pepperoni and Chorizo Crumbles
Classic pizza topper meets Spanish chorizo. Stir into pasta or sprinkle on pizza, focaccia, or salad.
RACHEL MAREK
Tastiest Marinated Tofu: Hodo Organic Indian Spiced Tofu
Pressed, marinated, and ready to heat, with enough leftover sauce to coat added vegetables.
RACHEL MAREK
Best Freezer-to-Pan Ground Meat: Pound of Ground Crumbles
Precrumbled for even cooking, a pound of frozen ground beef browns in 8 minutes.
RACHEL MAREK
Best Frozen Meatballs: Farm Rich Maple Bacon Meatballs
Finally a meatball that works for breakfast and dinner. Tuck into biscuits for anytime sliders.
RACHEL MAREK
Treat Yourself
If you have room in your pantry, we agreed these items are worth the splurge.
RACHEL MAREK
Best Fruit Preserve: Pika Pika Calamansi Marmalade
A tart spread made from the tiny Philippine calamansi— tangerine and lime in one.
RACHEL MAREK
Most Innovative Syrup Flavor: Torani Puremade Toasted Black Sesame Syrup
A splash in cold brew is a no-brainer, but also try this trending flavor in a savory spin like bulgogi beef or spring roll dipping sauce.
RACHEL MAREK
Best Fruit Vinegar: Kosterina Crushed Strawberry Vinegar
This vinegar is good enough to drink. Enjoy true fruit flavor in salads, on seafood, or in a cocktail.
RACHEL MAREK
Freshest-Tasting Jarred Sauce: Sonoma Gourmet Lemon and Herb Ricotta
We’re tossing this creamy ricotta sauce—vibrant with real citrus juice—in pasta with salmon and spinach.
RACHEL MAREK
Most Versatile Flavored Olive Oil: Brightland Rosemary Olive Oil
Wildly aromatic, it makes the kitchen smell incredible. Use as a bread dipper or drizzle lightly over roasted veggies.
RACHEL MAREK
Best Tinned Fish: Sea Tales Sardines in Spicy Tomato Sauce
"This is a great way to introduce someone to sardines,” says Erin Hooker, assistant food editor and tinned-fish enthusiast.
RACHEL MAREK
Best Truffle Butter: Isigny Ste.-Mère x Fabrique Délices Black Truffle Butter
Truffle is back! This is our favorite use of the funky fungi.
RACHEL MAREK
Best Flavored Hot Honey: Red Clay Spicy Peach Honey
Testers were pleased by the sweet, natural peach taste in this “swicy” (sweet and spicy) honey.