Best Overall
Better Homes and Gardens Waterproof Cotton Mattress Pad
WALMART
- The mattress pad has a 250-thread count cotton cover.
The mattress pad has a 250-thread count cotton cover.
- This pick is only available in four standard sizes.
This pick is only available in four standard sizes.
After two months of testing, our favorite mattress pad is the Better Homes and Gardens Waterprood Cotton Mattress Pad. This pick is offered in four standard sizes and structured like a fitted sheet. Overall, we thought this option performed just as it should.
The top layer of this mattress pad is a soft and breathable 250-thread count cotton cover. Filling the cotton cover is batting made from a down alternative hypoallergenic polyester. A waterproof polyurethane layer on the bottom protects the bed from spills or middle-of-the-night accidents. Even after months of use and frequent washings, the waterproof layer remained in tact and effective.
This pad provided a light cushion layer, stayed perfectly in place during the even after some tossing and turning, and was quiet overall. The cushion is also smooth and consistentas well. Thanks to the wide elastic skirt, it’s easy to put this mattress pad on the bed, even by one person, and it will fit mattresses up to 22 inches thick.
Overall, we appreciated the price point of this pick and that it was machine washable as well. The only drawback is that it’s unavailable in twin XL or California king sizes, so it may not work for every bedroom.
Product Details: Sizes: Twin, full, queen, and king | Material: Cotton, down alternative, and polyurethane barrier | Care: Machine washable
Key Terms to Know
- Mattress Pad: A thin, quilted layer made to cover the surface of the mattress, providing a thin layer of padding and protecting your mattress from stains, spills, and wear and tear.
- Mattress Topper: A thicker layer of foam or quilting primarily designed for comfort, mattress toppers can range from one to three inches deep.
- BETTER HOMES and GARDENS / DERA BURRESON
BETTER HOMES and GARDENS / DERA BURRESON
Best Budget
Serta Power Clean Quilted Waterproof Mattress Pad
AMAZON
- This pick is available in various sizes.
This pick is available in various sizes.
- The skirt stretches up to 18 inches, which may be too small for deep mattresses.
The skirt stretches up to 18 inches, which may be too small for deep mattresses.
We tested the Serta Power Clean Quilted Waterproof Mattress Pad at home for two months and thought it was a great option for those who want a less expensive pick. It offered a thin layer of padding and protected our mattress well. Plus, we noted that it was soft and pillowy but not overly hot.
The mattress pad is offered in six sizes, making it a helpful option for stocking a vacation rental or updating your home’s mattress pads. During testing, we found it was easy to put on the bed and even though the skirt only stretches up to 18 inches, the pad did not move around or slip off in our tests.
In our spill tests, the mattress stayed dry, but the pad did get very wet. It doesn’t repel water but absorbs it, so we wondered if the damp pad is left on the mattress for a long time, it might eventually seep through to the mattress.
After prolonged use, we noticed the pad did sound a little crispy and drying the pad in the dryer was tricky. The material is waterproof, and it takes a while for it actually to get dry. This didn’t diminish its effectiveness and we still recommend this pick as a wonderful option, especially for accident-prone kids.
Product Details: Sizes: Twin, twin xl, full, queen, king, and California king | Material: Polyester | Care: Machine washable
- BETTER HOMES and GARDENS / DERA BURRESON
BETTER HOMES and GARDENS / DERA BURRESON
Best Splurge
Sijo Clima Tech TempTune Mattress Pad
SIJO
- The fabric blend is supposed to absorb body heat and maintain a consistent temperature.
The fabric blend is supposed to absorb body heat and maintain a consistent temperature.
- This pick is not available in twin or standard king size.
This pick is not available in twin or standard king size.
The Sijo TempTune Mattress Pad is more expensive than other picks but after two months of testing it at home, we think it’s worth the investment. Overall, we felt it was high-quality and we had few complains about it.
Crafted with an outer layer made from a Mica nylon blend with Tencil, the fill is Clima, which is supposed to adjust to your body temperature. After two months of testing,this pad showed no signs of wear and tear and continued to work well.
This pad claims to keep your body cool by absorbing extra body heat but redistributing heat if the temperature drops. While our we didn’t notice any significant benefits, we were not overly hot or cold with this mattress pad. Plus, we found a temperature difference between the slept-on side and the empty side of the bed.
The mattress pad fit well, did not emit any odors, and passed our waterproof test by keeping the mattress bone dry. Just note that this mattress pad is not available in twin or standard king sizes.
Product Details: Sizes: Full, queen, and California king | Material: Mica nylon blend, tencil, and clima | Care: Machine wash on cold
- BETTER HOMES and GARDENS / DERA BURRESON
BETTER HOMES and GARDENS / DERA BURRESON
Best Quilted
Matbeby Quilted Mattress Pad
AMAZON
- This option is offered in nine sizes.
This option is offered in nine sizes.
- This mattress pad is not waterproof.
This mattress pad is not waterproof.
A quilted mattress pad, like the Matbeby Quilted Mattress Pad, adds extra comfort to your bed without the bulk that some mattress toppers do.
This mattress pad comes in nine sizes-a rare distinction and a helpful resource if you’re looking for odd sizes, like an RV king mattress pad. It’s also available in seven colors, which is beneficial if you want something beyond the typical white mattress pad.
We found this pad comfortable, easy to put on, and not too bulky. This pick fit snugly on the mattress but the pad didn’t fully cover all the edges of the bed’s mattress. While the quilted squares keep the filling in place, the quilting did seem to get less plush after two months of use.
This mattress pad is not waterproof, so while it adds some comfort and a layer of protection, note that it will not keep your mattress dry from spills.
Product Details: Sizes: Twin, twin xl, full, full xl, queen, short queen, king, California king, and RV king | Material: Microfiber | Care: Machine washable
- BETTER HOMES and GARDENS / DERA BURRESON
BETTER HOMES and GARDENS / DERA BURRESON
Best Waterproof
The Company Store Cotton Jersey Waterproof Mattress Pad
THE COMPANY STORE
- This pad goes on the bed quickly and easily, like a fitted sheet.
This pad goes on the bed quickly and easily, like a fitted sheet.
- It’s pretty thin, so it’s not the best pick if you want one that adds comfort as well.
It’s pretty thin, so it’s not the best pick if you want one that adds comfort as well.
The Company Store Company Cotton Jersey Waterproof Mattress Pad gives you peace of mind and avoids late-night worries when bedtime accidents occur. Keep in mind that it doesn’t provide added fluff or comfort.
After two months of testing with a potty-training son, no less, this mattress held up well to the occasional nighttime accident. The mattress was never wet, and we appreciated how silent the pad is, especially since some waterproof pads are plastic and emit smells or noises.
The wetness protection is a crucial feature of this pad: It has two layers of cotton jersey fabric, with a polyurethane waterproof layer sandwiched between the cotton. This mattress pad provides excellent protection from spills and accidents. The ultra-thin pad is easy to put on the bed, and we like that it is available in two pocket depths: 11 and 18 inches.
This option goes on the bed like a fitted sheet. Along with the benefits of protection, the pad emits no odor, and thanks to the jersey cotton layers, it’s silent, even when tossing and turning on the bed. This mattress pad does not add plushness or provide heating or cooling benefits.
Product Details: Sizes: Twin, twin xl, full, queen, king, and California king | Material: Cotton jersey and waterproof barrier | Care: Machine washable
- BETTER HOMES and GARDENS / DERA BURRESON
BETTER HOMES and GARDENS / DERA BURRESON
Best Heated
Bedsure Heated Mattress Pad Queen Size
AMAZON
- Two controllers allow dual zones, and a 10-hour shut-off provides peace of mind.
Two controllers allow dual zones, and a 10-hour shut-off provides peace of mind.
- This heated pad is not water resistant.
This heated pad is not water resistant.
The Bedsure Heated Mattress Pad is a reliable if you want to add a heated mattress pad to your bed. While it has no frills, the mattress pad comes with two controllers, so it’s easy to achieve different heat levels on both sides of the bed.
Four temperature levels provide a custom level of comfort. During testing, the setup was easy, and after six months of consistent use, it still heated consistently, even after washing. This pick got high praise for quality, comfort, and affordability. However, this option only has four temperature levels, which is less than some other heated options.
A heated mattress pad requires easy access to electricity, and this pick needs two outlets, so make sure your bed is positioned near an appropriate outlet. While the pad can be machine washed, hang drying is recommended, and note that it is not water resistant.
Product Details: Sizes: Twin, twin xl, full, queen, and king | Material: Polyester | Care: Machine wash
- BETTER HOMES and GARDENS / HENRY WORTOCK
BETTER HOMES and GARDENS / HENRY WORTOCK
Best With Dual Control
Sunbeam Restful Quilted Heated Mattress Pad
AMAZON
- Dual controls each have 12 heat settings.
Dual controls each have 12 heat settings.
- This pad is not water resistant.
This pad is not water resistant.
An easy setup and a plush fabric make the Sunbeam Restful Quilted Heated Mattress Pad an excellent option if you’re looking for a dual-control heated mattress topper. It just needs access to one outlet, and each control has 12 heat settings, so each sleeper can get their exact level of needs met.
After six months of use, we found that this pick works great and felt that setting different temperatures for each person's side is a must-have for heated mattress pads. It's easy to use, reliable, and cozy as well. We did note, however, that the wires are pretty thick, which was one negative point of this pick.
While it’s not water resistant, the mattress pad allows for easy washing.It can be washed and dried in both machines and even after six months of frequent washing, there were no changes to the quality of the pad.
Product Details: Sizes: Twin, full, queen, and king | Material: Polyester | Care: Machine wash and dryer safe
- BETTER HOMES and GARDENS / HENRY WORTOCK
BETTER HOMES and GARDENS / HENRY WORTOCK